|
Pages 83, 84, 85: Formula (5.13), known as "Cardano's formula," is not as simple as it appears. When q2/4 + p3/27 is positive, it is straightforward, since the two numbers under the cube roots are real and each has a unique real cube root.
But when q2/4 + p3/27 is negative, formula (5.13) is ambiguous. The square root of q2/4 + p3/27 is then a non-real complex number, and so are the two numbers under the cube roots, which are moreover conjugates of one another.
Now, a nonzero complex number has three distinct cube roots, not just one: formula (5.13) is therefore not well-defined without a further specification.
For example, in formula (5.15), which has three real roots, if one takes the so-called "principal" cube root of 2+11i, namely 2+i, formula (5.16) gives x = (2+i) + (2−i) = 4; the other two roots of (5.15), −2−√3 and −2+√3, are obtained using the other determinations of the cube root.
For further details, see a textbook on complex numbers. |